SUMMARY OF THE ADJUDICATION

The unique feature of the Public Use Products Unit was the extremely wide range of entries. While we may be seeing the effects of this being the first competition of the 21st century, this may be due to going beyond the former narrow interpretation of the word "public" and using it literally to include a broad cross-section of product groups that have to do with people's lives. Most of the products seemed to embody one of the principles of the Chair of the Screening Committee, "Make user-friendliness a priority," and I believe that this demonstrates the fundamental ideals of public use products.

There was a total of 184 entries, or 30% more than last year. The overall level of design was also high, and in both the First and Second Adjudications, we needed to make quibbling distinctions, and we had one heated argument after another. We can safely say that this year's entries were several levels above last year's in terms of both quality and quantity. I must admit, though, that some products groups had not changed very much since last year, one example being educational products. It was somewhat regrettable that few products gave us a feeling for the definite changes that education is undergoing currently (even if those changes are proceeding more slowly than in the West). Similarly, few products offered something for the young heirs of the next century to dream about or offered strong suggestions for the future shape of education.

THE GOLD PRIZE WINNERS

Of all the products entered in this Unit, the one that attracted particular attention was Yamaha Motor's specially installed swimming pool SWIM 21. The powerful impression it made at the 9th FINA World Swimming Championships at Fukuoka in 2001 was not only an emotional experience to some degree but also left behind a fresh and innovative image. Many people know that the pool's 3 meter depth contributed to the setting of a number of new records, but it is surprising how few of them know that this pool was a special installation assembled for the occasion. Installing and assembling the main part of the pool, the side decks, the filtering materials, the pipes, and other components took two weeks, and disassembling it took one week. By installing and dismantling a pool at such an astonishing speed, Yamaha probably set some kind of a world record itself. It also set some kind of a world record for assembled pools by being precisely built enough to pass the international certification standards for competitive swimming pools. Under the current situation, where the economics of using arenas and gymnasiums and other large facilities efficiently are viewed as problematic, these specially installed assembled unit system pools are expected to provide one of the answers. It has played a major role in suggesting the direction design might take in the 21st century.
Furthermore, its joining technology, which can withstand 3 tons of pressure per square meter, its FRP, which can hold up under long-term repeated use, the composite modules of its basic concrete panels, its soundproofing structure, which prevents poolside sounds from reaching the swimmers, and other finely detailed design concepts are right on the mark to meet the task assigned to G-Mark goods in the 21st century, namely, "promoting exports of intangible ideas from Japan to the world."

Another attention-grabbing product was Kongo's high-power storage system HPZ. On the surface, it looks like a simply and economically finished mobile shelf, but this storage system is a veritable cornucopia of good ideas in that its components exemplify the concepts of user friendliness, greater safety, and greater economy, as well as being marvelously integrated.
The special feature of what might be called a hybrid mobile shelf include the action of the shelves as they open and close like sliding doors with a grip-style touch switch. Thanks to a combination of a compact inverter designed in-house and a DC motor, it starts to move in an almost uncanny way, sliding quietly with 80 to 100 grams of hand pressure, even when loaded with 10 tons. It stops smoothly, quickly, and easily because of its anti-lock braking system. It also serves as an anti-vibration function which prevents the doors from opening unexpectedly during an earthquake. If any document or even one digital data medium (CD, CD-ROM, or MO, for example) falls, the system quickly stop the shelf. Of course, the locks are activated when people are inside.

It also fully meets the need for one of the greatest concerns of the IT era, storage of digital data, and its fireproof materials, developed by NASA to withstand temperatures of 1,300 degrees centigrade, are smartly finished. Removal and storage of data are detected by installed sensors, and the items removed from inventory are recorded and can be searched at any time by computer. A security camera is installed to ensure the safety of the people working inside the shelves, and the system that allows monitoring from the outside will also become a required item in the coming years.
Ventilation is provided by a thin titanium oxide air purifying system that is patented worldwide and quietly blows fresh air in from the front. This not only aids the preservation of documents and digital data but also makes the entire space a healthier and more comfortable environment. Despite being loaded with many high tech functions, it seems gentle on the whole, and it has a way of putting at ease the people who come into contact with it. This may be the harbinger of new forms of user friendliness and human-machine interfaces that will be demanded in the coming era. I would also like to add that the concept of Japan's traditional form of universal design, fusuma-style sliding doors, has been marvelously put to work in this high-tech machine. We also gave this product high marks because of the way that North European designers have learned directly from this particular sterling quality of Japanese design.

In the preceding, I have mentioned two entries that were worthy of special recognition, but both Yamaha Motor's SWIM 21 and Kongo's HPZ have both been recognized for the strength of their proposals and their creative concepts, SWIM 21 for its vision of future sporting events and HPZ as a management system that brings about the harmony between people and information that will be needed in the IT era. The entire Screening Committee gave them superior marks for opening new markets for 21st-century-style public use products.


Shinichi Yamamura
Chief Jury of Public Use Unit
President, COBO DESIGN CO., LTD.